NXT Match Of The Year Nominees:
- WarGames Match (TakeOver: WarGames)
- Johnny Gargano vs. Andrade “Cien” Almas (NXT Championship Match, TakeOver: Philadelphia)
- Moustache Mountain vs. Undisputed ERA (NXT Tag Team Championship Match, NXT TV, July 11, 2018)
- Johnny Gargano vs. Tommaso Ciampa (Unsanctioned Match, TakeOver: New Orleans)
- NXT North American Championship Ladder Match (TakeOver: New Orleans)
- Kairi Sane vs. Shayna Baszler (NXT Women’s Championship Match, TakeOver: Brooklyn IV)
- Ricochet vs. Velveteen Dream (TakeOver: Chicago)
- Aleister Black vs. Tommaso Ciampa (NXT Championship Match, NXT TV, July 25)
- Pete Dunne vs. Zack Gibson (WWE U.K. Championship Match, NXT TV, Aug. 22)
- Aleister Black vs. Adam Cole (Extreme Rules Match, TakeOver: Philadelphia)
- Pete Dunne vs. Kyle O’Reilly (WWE U.K. Championship Match, NXT TV, June 13)
- Danny Burch & Oney Lorcan vs. Undisputed ERA (TakeOver: Chicago)
- Nikki Cross vs. Bianca Belair (NXT TV, Sept. 12)
- Ricochet vs. Pete Dunne (NXT North American Champion vs. WWE U.K. Champion Match, NXT TV, Sept. 19)
- Ricochet vs. Pete Dunne vs. Adam Cole (NXT North American Championship Triple Threat Match, NXT TV, Oct. 10)
NXT Female Competitor of the Year Nominees:
- Nikki Cross
- Shayna Baszler
- Kairi Sane
- Ember Moon
- Bianca Belair
NXT Male Competitor Of The Year Nominees:
- Tommaso Ciampa
- Johnny Gargano
- Ricochet
- Aleister Black
- Velveteen Dream
- Andrade “Cien” Almas
- Adam Cole
- Pete Dunne
Overall Competitor of the Year Nominees:
- Tommaso Ciampa
- Nikki Cross
- Johnny Gargano
- Ricochet
- Shayna Baszler
- Aleister Black
- Kairi Sane
- Velveteen Dream
- Andrade “Cien” Almas
- Ember Moon
- Adam Cole
- Pete Dunne
- Bianca Belair
